Custom Cakes

A few words about our cakes...

The prices listed below are the starting points for a standard cake. If items or additional colors are added, then the prices are adjusted.


Below is what is included for a standard cake:

 - 2 flavors of ice cream

 - 1 middle layer (ex: chocolate crunchies)

 - White or Pastel icing

 - 1 Color of pastel or white icing

 - Sprinkles of your choosing

 - 1 Large 3D printed cake topper


Why does it take 3-5 days to make a cake? 

Our cakes are made fresh when ordered and we extract your cake right from our ice cream maker at the same time as ice cream is made for the shop. We produce ice cream Monday through Friday, so if you submit an order on a Friday morning, we may have already completed ice cream production for that week. This means your cake won't be created until Monday and it has to freeze overnight. And finally on Tuesday morning, it will be decorated to your specs and that right there is 5 days.  

Why are *pastel* colors included in the price and not vibrant colors?
We use natural or organic coloring in a
lmost all of our ice cream flavors. We use those same colors for our icing & piping therefor we can only achieve a pastel color and since we already have the coloring, there isn't an additional cost. We can buy artificial coloring to attain the vibrant colors that some people would like, however it's an additional cost for that option. Please plan for that if you select vibrant colors and be mindful that those are FD&C colors.

Why are multiple 3D cake toppers more money?
We have cake toppers already designed for our cakes and only have to adjust for the different names requested by customers. If you would like multiple cake toppers, we have to design new toppers, which takes time. Additionally, if different colors are selected, the material (PLA) needs to be switched out and a new print needs to be started for each pick.

Cake Topper Shapes

Each cake topper will have some sort of shape attached to the words. The reason for this is to stabilize the words to the pick to ensure the letters don't pop off the pick. We've selected a couple different stars. If you would like a different shape, like a heart for example, we can do that. You'll need to fill in the field below to describe what you would like to substitute. If you do not write something in that field, expect to receive stars.

Ordering & Payment Options

You can stop in the store to place an order & pre-pay in person -or- you can order online & pay online.

If you place an order online, a SQUARE invoice will be sent to your email within a day or two after you submit your order. Please make sure to check ALL of your email folders for this Square invoice.  

Custom Cake Order Form

If you're ready to order, please fill in the necessary fields and we'll get your cake started on the next available business day (that's when we make our fresh ice cream)

Let's Build Your Cake...

Cake Size
Select Middle Layer

Now Let's Decorate It...

Icing Color
Piping Color (ONE Light color included). Addt'l light colors, add $1.00)
Vibrant Colors (FD&C coloring, Add $2.00)

Final Touches...

Sprinkle Selection (These will be added around the edge of the cake where the piping is. If you don't want these, leave the field unmarked.)
3D Printed Cake Topper

Example of One Color Topper

Choose the Color or Colors for your cake topper message

Almost Done...



10930 US Hwy 1 N,

Suite B

Ponte Vedra, FL 32081


Tel: 904-342-0663



Mon - Thur    12pm-9pm

Friday           12pm-9pm

Sat & Sun      12pm-9pm


©2017 by Chilled Flavors. Proudly created with