Pre-Ordering is now CLOSED. 

We always make a few extra pies so maybe we'll have some available.

To all those who have pre-order, THANK YOU so much for supporting our business with your purchase.

Pie pick up can happen from 12-9pm on the day you've selected or after.

Merry Christmas & Happy New Year! 

With Thanksgiving over, it's now time to pre-order your favorite holiday pies. Our pies are packed with over 2 lbs of our handmade ice cream. Each handmade pie shell is made with either a graham cracker crust or our very own chocolate crunch crust (featured in Amy's Favorite ice cream). To compliment these delicious 10" pies are sauces, icing, candies and festive sprinkles to decorate the top. 


An invoice will be sent within a couple of days after you submit your order. If you'd rather pay at the shop, please note that in the comments section below.
Here are the pies we're offering for this season.  


Candy Cane Pie~ $20.00

Candy Cane is our top seller and for good reason. This pie has our signature chocolate crunchie crust and our freshly made Candy Cane ice cream compliments it so well. It's topped with crushed candy canes,

starlight mints & generous dollops of vanilla icing. If you like candy canes, you will *not* be disappointed, order one today.

Peppermint Bark Pie ~ $20.00        (not pictured)

This seasonal ice cream has been so popular in the past, we've decided to use it in one of our holiday pies! This pie will also have our signature chocolate crunchie crust paired with our rich chocolate ice cream, slightly mint vanilla ice cream and chunks of peppermint bark chocolate. This marbleized pie will be topped with pieces of peppermint bark chocolate candy & dollops of whipped topping.

Sugar Cookie Dough ~ $20.00          (Not pictured)

This new pie is sure to please kids of all ages. From the chocolate crunch pie shell, to the sugar cookie ice cream flavor, this homemade dessert will be memorable for those who love cookies & cookie dough! This pie will feature adorable holiday sprinkles & dollops of whipped cream! 

Salted Caramel & Chocolate Brownie ~ $20.00    (Not pictured)

This next scrumptious pie will have a chocolate crunch crust and filled with our swirled salted caramel & chocolate brownie ice cream. It will be topped with a hot fudge drizzle pattern, with whipped cream dollops along the edge, topped by chocolate dust.

I Love Amy ~ $20.00

This pie has our signature chocolate crunchie crust and is filled with Amy's Favorite ice cream (vanilla ice cream with a peanut butter swirl & chocolate crunchies). Along the edge are dollops whipped cream covered by chocolate crunchies with the top drizzled with Reese's peanut butter sauce and hot fudge.

Chocolate Peanut Butter ~ $20.00

This pie has our signature chocolate crunch crust and filled with our chocolate peanut butter ice cream that has peanut butter AND Reese's peanut butter cups swirled into it. The ring around the outside is crushed Reese's Peanut Butter Cups and it's topped with a peanut butter & hot fudge drizzle.

Holiday Sampler 1 ~ $20.00              (Not Pictured)

You can't please everyone with just one flavor, right?!? This pie has 4 of our delicious flavors and depending on how you slice your pie, you can get 2 pieces of each! For this sampler, we've got Candy Cane pie, Sugar Cookie Dough pie, Salted Caramel Chocolate Brownie pie and Amy's Favorite pie!!! Enjoy! 

Holiday Sampler 2 ~ $20.00              (Not Pictured)

The Sampler 1 pie just wasn't enough, so we created another pie with different flavors! This pie has 4 of our delicious flavors and depending on how you slice your pie, you can get 2 pieces of each! For our Holiday Sampler 2, we've got Candy Cane pie, Peppermint Bark pie, Salted Caramel Chocolate Brownie pie and Chocolate Peanut Butter pie!!!

Ice Cream Pie
Order Form
Select the pie(s) you'd like to order:

Thank you for ordering! An invoice will be emailed to you shortly.