With Thanksgiving over, it's now time to pre-order your favorite holiday pies. Our pies are packed with over 2 lbs of our handmade ice cream. Each handmade pie shell is made with either a graham cracker crust or our very own chocolate crunch crust (featured in Amy's Favorite ice cream). To compliment these delicious 10" pies are sauces, icing, candies and cookies to decorate the top. We also offer a gluten free graham crust for those with allergies**.
An invoice will be sent within a couple of days after you submit your order. If you'd rather pay at the shop, please note that in the comments section below.
Here are the pies we're offering for this season.  

Candy Cane ~ $18.00    (Dairy Free also available)

Candy Cane is our top seller and for good reason. This pie has our signature chocolate crunchie crust and our freshly made Candy Cane ice cream compliments it so well. It's topped with crushed candy canes,

starlight mints & generous dollops of vanilla icing. If you like candy canes, you will *not* be disappointed, order one today.

Santa's Cookies ~ $18.00

Santa loves his cookies and so do we! This pie will also have our signature chocolate crunchie crust paired with our rich vanilla bean ice cream that's packed with Santa's favorite cookies: Oreos, Chocolate chip cookies & Nutter Butters. To finish this beauty, the top will be adorned by one of the cookies pictured here, dollops of red, green & white vanilla icing and Christmas sprinkles. 

Frozen Snowflakes ~ $18.00

This new pie is sure to please kids of all ages. From the chocolate crunch pie shell, to the white chocolate ice cream flavor, this homemade dessert will be memorable for those who love sparkles & warm hugs. This pie will feature light purple, blue & teal icing & sprinkles, with dollops of vanilla icing and one of the cookies pictured here! 

Salted Caramel ~ $18.00

This next scrumptious pie will have a chocolate crunch crust and filled with our salted caramel ice cream. It will be topped with a hot fudge & caramel drizzle pattern, with vanilla icing dollops along the edge, topped by chocolate dust.

I Love Amy ~ $18.00

This pie has our signature chocolate crunchie crust and is filled with Amy's Favorite ice cream (vanilla ice cream with a peanut butter swirl & chocolate crunchies). Along the edge are dollops of vanilla icing covered by chocolate crunchies with the top drizzled with Reese's peanut butter sauce and hot fudge.

S'Mores ~ $18.00       (Gluten Free also available)

This fun yet decadent pie has a delicious graham cracker crust smothered with chocolate & marshmallow sauce. It's filled with our rich chocolate ice cream and topped with mini marshmallows, chopped chocolate, more marshmallow sauce and a surprise along the pie's edge.

Chocolate Peanut Butter ~ $18.00

This pie has our signature chocolate crunch crust and filled with our chocolate peanut butter ice cream that has peanut butter AND Reese's peanut butter cups swirled into it. The ring around the outside is crushed Reese's Peanut Butter Cups and it's topped with a peanut butter & hot fudge drizzle.

**Allergy Note: We hand make the crusts with wheat & dairy products. 

Ice Cream Pie
Order Form
Select the pie(s) you'd like to order:



10930 US Hwy 1 N,

Suite B

Ponte Vedra, FL 32081


Tel: 904-342-0663



Mon - Thur    12pm-9pm

Friday           12pm-9pm

Sat & Sun      12pm-9pm


©2017 by Chilled Flavors. Proudly created with